Thanks for the detailed breakdown, I genuinely appreciate the technical explanation.
I agree that inside-out optical tracking generally fails in more obvious ways (blocked camera, LED failure, battery disconnect etc.), and I’m not suggesting the tracking algorithm itself is “wearing out.”
When I describe it as gradual degradation, I mean the user experience has progressively become less reliable over time - not that the underlying tracking system is mechanically decaying in a linear way.
A few clarifications:
- This isn’t about missing more notes due to skill progression. The issue presents as occasional controller position jumps or momentary micro-loss during swings that previously registered cleanly.
- It occurs even on slower, controlled maps where speed ceiling isn’t a factor.
- I’ve tested with conscious grip/form adjustments to rule out posture drift.
- It’s consistent across rooms and across standalone vs PCVR.
I completely accept that optical tracking systems don’t “degrade” in a software sense. My concern is whether there could be:
- LED output dimming slightly over time (not total failure, but reduced intensity).
- Subtle battery contact wear causing very brief voltage dips
- Internal IMU drift that only becomes noticeable during high acceleration
- Long-term wear that doesn’t produce catastrophic failure but affects edge-case performance
I’m not married to the hardware-failure explanation - I’m trying to rule things out before replacing controllers or a total headset upgrade.
Just to clarify on the environmental side - the test space is fairly minimal. There are no ceiling fans, TVs, glossy frames, motion detectors, LED strips, mirrors, or reflective surfaces in the play area. The lighting is a single standard LED bulb with a fabric lampshade, and I’ve also tested in a second location with similar results.
If you (or anyone else) have suggestions for how to objectively test LED strength or detect micro-disconnects, I’d be very open to trying that. I’d much rather identify a concrete cause than assume replacement is the only path.
Appreciate the input.