Transferring app ownership of app I developed

I have two organizations, I am the admin of both. I want to transfer ownership of one of my apps from one to the other. I go to the organizations panel and find the 'transfer apps' option, but the app I want to transfer is grayed out and when I hover over it I see:

"This app belongs to an app grouping that contains an approved app."

Is there some other way to transfer apps that have been approved? Or do I need to set up an entirely new app? This would be annoying because I already users, ratings, and reviews.

Thanks!