Rogue One, Star Wars.. Comments.??

Jesus is better security? Don't think so mate.

The security was so good that the attack was a suicide mission. I'm pretty sure that counts as amongst the best security possible.

Zenbane said:

The security was so good that the attack was a suicide mission. I'm pretty sure that counts as amongst the best security possible.

If I was the Imperial Empire, I would have just destroyed the communications dish at the top of the data storage tower.
Simple logic really. 
What's up with the CGI commander. That is so lame.. honestly.. just get a real actor.

Biggest problem with Rogue One: they left out Kyle Katarn!
It was Kyle that stole the death star plans in the lucas arts game Dark Forces.

Kyle was an ex imperial soldier who became a mercenary, then a jedi. He walked the line between the light and dark side, used guns in addition to a light saber, and was just a cool character, and even had a real actor for the video cut scenes.

But thanks to disney, Kyle's part in the Starwars story has been removed. :(

I really liked it and preferred parts of it to Force Awakens, Force awakens was a very safe film and didn't try push anything too far, which was the strong point to Rogue One, I didn't feel like they were holding back in-case they upset the fans.

Rogue One has an great film aesthetic, it was shot like an old war film, and had the best cinematography of all the newer films, I felt like you could pause it at any moment and it would make a great poster.

Bringing Peter Cushing back to life was a high point to the movie and extremely creepy at the same time !!!

I'm just wondering how many times I'm going to have to watch all the Star Wars films to see them in the correct order??

Pure cheese and cameos (maybe I'll ask for that next time I'm ordering a pizza) but sometimes when you remove the critical head it's just nice to kick back and be entertained for what it is.

molokow said:

What's up with the CGI commander. That is so lame.. honestly.. just get a real actor.

Because they wanted the original Tarkin. I'd agree though, it wasn't good enough for a character that featured as much as he did. Would have been great if it had been a full CGI movie, but not when replacing one alongside real actors.

I have a better chance of getting a job with the imperial force than these people. Dont they predict outcomes?
Seriously, Seriously. Get some people in a room watching security cameras around vulnerable areas in the base. 

First thing I would do is take my army to a shooting range. I mean fark me.. talk about bad shots.
It appears you need about 20 storm troopers to shoot 1 individual target to hit it an even then !