Rogue One, Star Wars.. Comments.??

molokow said:

Seriously, Seriously. Get some people in a room watching security cameras around vulnerable areas in the base.

They did, and Ip Man died trying to push a button. You sure you watched the whole movie? lol

So you're concerned that the security camera system wasn't realistic but had no problem with all the other stuff that clearly doesn't exist like light sabers and faster-than-light space travel?

cybereality said:

So you're concerned that the security camera system wasn't realistic but had no problem with all the other stuff that clearly doesn't exist like light sabers and faster-than-light space travel?

Light sabers and Jedi are real Cyber.
I thought the Droid was the best part about the movie.

I mean ... what would I know, I just do strategical analysis.


Ok guys, we got intruders in the base.
Let's send out the worst shooters in our army. 

Additionally, who the hell put a hard drive port accessible at the top of the communications tower??
I am going to fire that guy.

molokow said:

Ok guys, we got intruders in the base.

Let's send out the worst shooters in our army.

I mean this in the nicest way possible... but you kinda just gave a metaphor for your posting style lol

Also, while the shooters are really bad, they did end up killing all the intruders. I've said this 3 times already, but you don't seem interested in the fact that this was a suicide mission. Probably because it kind of ruins your entire complaint strategy here. Which is similar to storm trooper strategy.

Zenbane, the kill ratio is astronomical. 
40 storm troopers to 1 Rebel. 
I mean seriously, stupid.
The storm troopers looked militarily trained and disciplined, yet cant fire straight.

They storm troopers did not kill the last 2 rebels. In fact, they thought it necessary to destroy the whole base because of a handful of rebels.
Ridiculous !

It was not meant to be a suicide mission, it was just the death star blew up the whole base.
There was the risk of suicide and they didnt suicide they were murdered.
 

molokow said:

There was the risk of suicide and they didnt suicide they were murdered.
 

Right, they were all murdered because the defenses were really good. But you keep arguing otherwise.

Anyway, my suggestion is for you to stick to documentaries.

Also, there were 7 other Star Wars movies that came before this one, where Storm Troopers became legends for their overwhelming ability to miss. Unless this is your first Star Wars movie... then I have no idea what you tricked yourself in to believing.

molokow said:

The storm troopers looked militarily trained and disciplined, yet cant fire straight.

It's not so easy to fire when wearing a large helmet with a low field of view. :)

Also, if the rebel attack was (realistically) squashed, the movie would have lasted 45 minutes, everyone you cared about would have died, and the whole movie would have been a real downer.

Yeah, you mentioned they sent out their worst shooters. All previous evidence would indicate these guys were the Empire's best.

I mean... they had a couple of dozen troopers firing a barrage of shots at Chirrut and one of them actually managed to hit him. That's crack-shot marksmanship as far as these guys are concerned.  :D

Zenbane said:

molokow said:

There was the risk of suicide and they didnt suicide they were murdered.
 

Right, they were all murdered because the defenses were really good. But you keep arguing otherwise.

Anyway, my suggestion is for you to stick to documentaries.

Also, there were 7 other Star Wars movies that came before this one, where Storm Troopers became legends for their overwhelming ability to miss. Unless this is your first Star Wars movie... then I have no idea what you tricked yourself in to believing.

It wasnt there defenses that stopped them escaping. That was only part of it.
They ran out of time to get a ship to escape.